Japanese beef curry (Curry Rice)
Japanese curry belongs to the group of typically Japanese foods that have origins in European cuisine, called yohshoku. Curry is tremendously popular in Japan - it's on the menu at just about every 'family' restaurant and department store restaurants, and there are curry-only restaurants as well as ones that specialize in high class yohshoku in general.
Japanese curry, called curry rice (or kareh raisu) since it's always served with rice, is not much like the curries from India, Thai or other places with better known curries around the world. The best way to describe it is probably to say it's like a English style stew with curry. (It's not at all like the curries you get in modern Britain, which are firmly in the Indian or Pakistani curry families.)
If you've ever been to a Japanese grocery store, you've probably seen the blocks or bags of curry base taking up an inordinate amount of shelf space. Competition amongst curry base makers in Japan is fierce. The bases are pretty convenient to use, but these days I use them less and less, since I discovered that making curry properly from scratch is not that much more effort than making curry with a readymade curry base. Commercial curry bases contain things like sugar or corn syrup as ingredients, plus some of them use mystery fats (always check the ingredient lists). I add sweetness just via the vegetables, especially a huge mound of slowly sautéed onions.
Either way, to get the most flavorful curry takes a long time. This is definitely a slow-cook meal.
This recipe for beef curry can be adapted to other kinds of meat, or to vegetarian options too. I've included instructions for using a store bought curry base as well as making your own curry roux base.
Japanese style beef curry
Makes about 6 to 8 servings.
- 450-500g / about 1 lb stewing beef cubes (chuck works well; it should be a cut with a bit of fat in it and not too sinewy)
- 6 large onions, or about 6 cups sliced
- 3 cloves garlic
- An adult thumb-sized piece of fresh ginger
- 2 cups of crushed tomatoes (1 small can, or 400g)
- 1 beef or vegetable stock cube (I prefer Knorr)
- 1 bay leaf
- 1 star anise
- 2-3 Tbs. garam masala (see notes)
- 3-4 large carrots
- 1 medium eating-type apple
- 3-4 medium potatoes
- Oil or butter
- Optional: 1 cup frozen green peas
- Salt and pepper
For the curry roux:
- 3 Tbs. butter, ghee, clarified butter or oil, or a mixture
- 4 Tbs. white flour
- 1 1/2 to 2 Tbs. curry powder, or more to taste (see notes)
To serve with:
- Plain white steamed Japanese rice, or plain brown rice
- Garnishes: fukijin zuke, rakkyou
Special equipment recommended: a heavy-bottomed enamelled cast iron pot (Le Creuset etc.) (but any decently heavy pot will do. A thin walled pot leads to burned curry. Burned curry ranks near the top of things that are Not Nice.)
If the meat is in one big chunk, cut into cubes about 2 cm / 1 inch square. Pat dry with paper towels, and brown in a little oil on all sides in a frying pan. Set aside.
Slice the onions thinly. Grate the ginger and either grate or finely chop the garlic. (A microplane is great for this task, if you have one.) Peel and cut the carrots into chunks. Don't peel the potatoes yet: this will come later.
Heat your heavy-bottomed pot over medium heat, and heat up some butter, ghee or oil. (Butter or ghee will add some richness but oil is fine - you will barely notice the subtle difference since the curry will overwhelm it.) Add the onions and a pinch of
salt, and lower the heat to medium-low. Now comes a period of long, slow cooking of the onions that can take up to an hour or so (the salt helps it along as it extracts the moisture in the onions). At the end you want to end up with a much reduced mass of onion that is a light caramel brown in color, as in the photo.
Once the onions have reached this stage, add the ginger and garlic and cook a few more minutes. Add the canned tomato and 6 cups of water, the browned beef, the stock cube, the bay leaf and the star anise. (If you are particular you can put these in a bit of cheese cloth or a tea ball for easy extraction later.)
Peel and grate the apple and stir in. (This is optional, but adds to the depth of flavor.)
Bring up to a boil, then lower the heat and simmer for at least 1 hour, or more if your meat is a bit tough.
About 30 minutes into the cooking process, dry-roast about a tablespoon of garam masala powder in a small frying pan until it starts to get very fragant, and add to the stew pot. Add the carrots around then too.
In the meantime, make the curry roux. In a small frying pan, melt the butter or ghee or clarified butter (note that ghee is basically clarified butter) and heat until any foaming subsides.
Add the flour, and cook the mixture over medium-low heat, stirring constantly, until it becomes a light brown in color. (See these very detailed instructions for roux if you aren't sure.)
Take the pan off the heat, and add the curry powder (the more the hotter.) Stir until the whole kitchen and beyond smells like curry. Set aside.
When the meat is about as tender as you want, peel the potatoes, cut them into chunks and add to the curry. Continue simmering until the potatoes are tender.
Take the pot off the heat and fish out the bay leaf and star anise. Stir in the roux carefully until it's completely melted into the stew and the liquid is thick and very brown. Return to the heat and simmer a few more minutes.
At this stage you can dry roast another tablespoonful or so of garam masala and add it to the curry.
At the last minute, add the optional frozen green peas, and stir - they should cook almost instantaneously. Serve immediately.
There are two ways of serving curry in the "yohshoku restaurant" way. One is to put the curry in a sauce boat, and serve the rice separately. The other is to put the rice on the plate, and cover just one half with curry, You can of course just pour the curry right on the mound of rice.
Usual garnishes are fukijin zuke, a sweet mixture of mystery pickled vegetables, and rakkyou, small pickled shallots. Other garnishes include chutney and grated cheese.
Notes
I don't go to the trouble of grinding my own curry and garam masala, much as I'd like to in theory. I use pre-ground powders bought at a store that caters to Indian and Sri Lankan expats. The most common Japanese brand of curry powder is S & B, but the Indian kind is quite a bit cheaper and just as good quality. Garam masala is not commonly sold in Japanese groceries anyway, but it is of course in Indian groceries.
Update: I have written up the Japanese curry powder formula for people who would like to experiment with mixing their own. (Includes a recipe for garam masala too.)
If you want it to be yellower, add some turmeric. If you want it hotter, add some chili pepper powder, or more curry powder.
Instead of, or in addition to, the grated apple, you can add some chutney, a tablespoon or so of honey, Worcestershire sauce, ketchup, and even a bit of soy sauce or miso.
Using a readymade curry base
If you are using a curry base instead of making your own curry roux, just add it in exactly the same way near the end of the cooking process, making sure to take the pot off the heat first. If you have the block that looks like a chocolate bar type, break it up into smaller chunks and stir in to the stew mix until all is melted. The bagged powder type melts in faster. The curry should not be stewed for a very lengthy time after adding the base or spices or the flavors will dissipate somewhat.
Many Japanese housewives individualize their curries by combining two or more commercial bases.
Using other meats
Pork curry is made in the same way as beef curry, but you may want to try making the curry a bit hotter (by adding more curry powder or chili pepper powder).
Chicken curry is best made with the dark meat parts (thigh works great). I also prefer to take the skin off first - curry-stewed chicken skin is not that nice. The stewing time for chicken curry is shorter since you don't want the chicken to get dried out.
Quick and easy ground beef curry
If this all sounds like too much work, you can still make a quick and easy curry using ground beef or other ground meat, and a commercial curry base. (Commercial curry base blocks are so big because they have a ton of flavor enhancing ingredients in them already.) Adam Kuban has posted a quick and fairly easy method for making a curry this way, though I would recommend sautéeing the onions a bit longer than he does, and adding the potatoes somewhat later in the process.
If you are in a huge curry..I mean hurry, you can buy readymade curry in a pouch. They vary quite a lot in quality so try some until you find a brand you like.
Making it vegetarian
You can omit the meat and use oil instead of butter or ghee, and have a vegetarian curry. If you want some protein, try a can of chickpeas. Cooked soy beans also fit very well. You can go the TVP - quorn route if you like too. Or go for an all-vegetable curry and add more carrots, or some sliced eggplant (aubergine), cubed turnip, etc.
Freezing curry
Curry freezes and reheats very well, as long as you leave out the potatoes. Frozen potato turns into a mealy, watery, inedible mush. Just add some boiled potatoes to the reheated curry. Since it does take a long time to cook it does make sense to make a big batch at a time and freeze extra for quick meals in the future.






Browning onions
Maki,
Did you happen to see the urawaza video on browning onions faster? After slicing the onions, you put them in a bowl and sprinkle it with salt. Then you mix it up and and let it sit for a while and drain the water out every once in a while. I think in the video, it took at least 1/2 the time (if I remember right).
I’ve tried it a few times and it is a lot faster, although I wonder if onion flavor gets drained out with the water too…
I do add a pinch of salt
Curry fan, I do add a pinch of salt to the onions though I don’t put them in a bowl and toss. I remember watching that urawaza video, but I don’t remember the details. Maybe I will try the tossing with salt trick next time…though I do wonder like you whether some flavor goes out with the liquid or not.
Spice blend
Maki,
Thank you for this post on making Japanese curry from scratch. I have scowered the internet for Japanese curry recipies and they always start with, “Buy a box of curry roux… “. Blech! Why feed the corporate machine when we can stick-it-to-the-man by making our own roux. Kudos to you for raising the bar. But… what I REALLY would like to know… if you know… what is the secret blend of 15 spices (or up to 20 according the to Village Voice article) that define the flavor of Japanese curry? I make my own curry powder (Indian) with which I flavor my udon and various cuts of meat. It is delicious, but it does not remotely resemble Japanese curry. I am at a loss. Can you help?
Lomo
curry powder
Hi Lomo,
It got a bit long for a comment so I’ve written it up here . I think it would need some experiementation but it’s a starting point anyway. Have fun!
A recipe for rice curry on a
A recipe for rice curry on a food blog?! What next, yakisoba? Omurice? Ketchup spaghetti?
Rice curry is the chicken fingers/mac & cheese of Japan. It exists solely to feed picky children. And mom can feel like she’s “cooking,” even though the core of the dish is a trans-fat filled chocolate bar. Making it from “scratch” reminds me of the gourmet mac & cheese boom of a couple years ago.
I take great pride in taking
I take great pride in taking all day making my Japanese curry. Yes, curry is comfort food, but it is not “crap” food as you seem to think. And last time I checked, I was neither picky nor a child. To keep it legit, for the rest of you folks is my curry recipe. And thank you Maki, you have given me some new ideas. ((cackles madly))
Japanese Curry
So, I found this in a Nitty-Gritty Cookbook from 1969. This is after much experimenting and modification.
Serves 8-10
10 cups of Beef Broth
4 large boneless, skinless chicken breasts
8 medium carrots, coined
2 medium onions, chopped
Either 6 medium Russet potatoes OR 12 yucan golds, cut into bite size pieces
2 large Japanese sweet potatoes (they’re purple!)
6-8 red tomatoes, cut into bit size pieces
1 head of garlic, minced (you could use less, but it’s tasty this way)
2 Tbs of mango chutney
½ tsp of fresh ground ginger
1 fugi apple, grated OR about 2 Tbs of unsweetened apple sauce
2- 4 Tbs of “Oriental Curry” powder (depending on how spicy you want it, and I do use the S&W brand)
3 tsp of soy sauce
4 Tbs of cornstarch
2-3 oz of smoked Gouda cheese
2 tsp of cultured buttermilk or liquid buttermilk
salt to taste
1.In a skillet, brown the vegetables together (if they don’t all fit, try browning the garlic with the onions, all of the potatoes together, then the carrots and tomatoes)
2.Brown the chicken. While doing this, bring the beef broth to a near boil in a 10 quart pot. Depending on how big the veggies and chicken come out to be, you might need a bigger pot.
3.When the browned ingredients are done, put in the broth. Stir well. Bring back to a near boil. In a small bowl, blend curry powder with cold water, enough to make into a smooth sauce. In a different small bowl, mix the cornstarch with a small amount of cold water, enough to make a smooth, thick sauce. Place curry powder in broth and stir in completely. Put chutney, ginger, apple, and soy sauce in. Stir in between each ingredient. Boil for about 30 minutes or until the potatoes are tender.
4.Turn down heat and add cornstarch. Stir until thick (like your spoon is standing up in it). Take off heat and shred in Gouda and buttermilk. Add salt just before serving. Serve over rice.
Some notes: I live near a farmers market and a Asian supermarket, so things are a bit easier to get. Most things can be omitted or substituted.
gouda and buttermilk
gouda and buttermilk in curry…. sounds odd yet oddly compelling. Thank you for posting the recipe!
I fail to see...
.. anything wrong with omurice, yakisoba, or for that matter mac and cheese or chicken fingers, if they are done right! Or curry rice either. Just because there are cardboard box versions of a food doesn’t mean that it’s inherently bad. I’m no food snob - if it’s good, it’s good.
Boxed Curry?
Hi, first of all, I love your blog! Second.. although I do appreciate you taking the time to outline a recipe for made-from-scratch curry, I was wondering if you could help me with the boxed curry I have, since I don’t necessarily have a lot of time to cook these days; also you seem like just the right person to ask. :) I have a few packages of S&B Golden Curry, and I’ve seen various recipes floating around, but most of them say to use the entire bar of the mix, (all of the roux?/the whole package?) and then recommend freezing it for later because it makes such a huge batch. My question is that I only want to make enough curry to feed 1-2 people at a time, preferably two, so how many smaller bars/(roux?) of the curry mix should I use? I was under the impression that if the whole box was five small bars/(roux?), then I could make enough to feed 2 people using just one small bar/(roux?). Hmm.. I guess basically what I want to know is how much curry could I make by using just one small bar piece/(roux?) instead of using the whole package/big bar/all five small bars. Thank you so very much!!
depends on the size of the box
Eve, S&B curry comes in two sizes. If you have the smaller one (100g size, or 3.5 oz) the pack says it should make about 6 servings, so for practical purposes half the box should make enough for 2 people. The big 200g box should make 12 servings they say so you need 1/4th. Keep in mind you’d need to reduce the amount of moisture in the dish accordingly too or you’ll end up with a very watery curry.
[quote]….contains mystery
….contains mystery fat
ha ha ha… gotta say… these words made me laught…. But so true…
anyway.. great recipe… homemade always taste good
Garam masala...
What is garam masala, and could it be omitted or replaced? I live in a very, very small town, far from more civilized stores - it’s a miracle we have mozzarella cheese!
Garam Marsala is an Indian
Garam Marsala is an Indian spice blend; not sure entirely what’s in it. McCormick has a “Gourmet Collection” of spices on the market, and you can buy Garam Marsala from them. I got a bottle of it from my local Wal-Mart. I live in a small town as well.
garam masala
Garam masala is an Indian spice mixture. If you omit it it would affect the flavor…though you can add some curry powder instead there (if you are in Japan). If you’re elsewhere I’m guessing garam masala is as easy to get a hold of (or as hard) as curry powder…
You can use allspice instead
You can use allspice instead of Garam masala with little to no difference :P
i don't agree
I think garam masala is more complex than allspice myself, but of course everyone’s tastebuds are different…
Re: garam masala
The term "garam masala" means 'heating' spices, or hot spices. Different cooks blend their own combination of spices to make their own unique garam masala. The heating spices are cinnamon, cloves, black pepper and black cardamom, and typical garam masala is an equal mixture of these 4 ingredients, but sometimes cooks use some of the 'cooling' spices of green cardamom, Indian bay leaf, and fennel (saunf). More elaborate chefs also use a wider array of spices, such as dried rose petals. It is best to grind your spices fresh just before using, and it is best when using whole spices, such as whole cloves, stick cinnamon, peppercorns, etc. If you grind or mix more garam masala than you are using at a time, you can store the remaining garam masala in a tightly-sealed bottle in a refrigerator for up to 6 months (best if used within 3 months).
I hope this helps somebody!
Amazing
Hi,
I find it amazing that last year around this time I was looking to make homemade tofu and found your site. This year I’ve been wanting to make my own curry roux and here you are again. Whats next on the menu… taiyaki? Anyway thanks for the instructions again, I can’t wait to try this one now.
hmm taiyaki
I don’t have a taiyaki plate so probably not… :) Though I’ve been thinking of dorayaki…
Home Made curry powder
Well today I finally made my own curry powder. I followed the ratios given, well kind of and came close to the taste I was seeking. Today was also the first time I added apples to the curry. The apples make it sooooo good. Thanks for all tips.
this is gold!
i have forever been searching for a recipe for japanese curry, this is gold my friend.
Calorie Count
I love your recipes here Maki-sensei and I was just wondering if you would happen to have already calculated the calories on this one. I need to keep track of my meals for a class at my college and just wanted to know if you had it on hand. I can do it myself but if you have it already I’d really appreciate it.
I really haven’t
I really haven’t calculated the calories for curry…because it is fairly high in calories because of the roux and so on, so I regard it as a ‘treat’ dish. It shouldn’t be too hard to calculate though.
curry roux or curry powder
hi..i wanna ask you all..i wanna make japanese curry, but in my place..curry roux and curry powder is not available here..can anybody help me how to make the curry?
I know you alluded to it
You mention cooked soybeans …something I always add (in lieu of, or in addition to the frozen green peas) is edamame. Great way to add flavor, protein, fiber, and other vitamins. I can’t believe after a ~year, I’m just now stumbling across this recipe here. Thanks!
Gluten-free curry?
Hi, I’ve been reading your blog for a while. I’ve tried a few of your recipes, and I love them! I have a friend coming to visit later this summer, and she has never tried curry, which is one of my favorite foods. I want to make it for her, but she has celiac disease, so she can’t have gluten. What could I substitute to make this recipe gluten-free? Would gluten-free flour or rice flour work instead?
I don’t have any
I don’t have any experience with gluten free flour, but I would try this: instead of making roux, just saute the spices in oil and add them, and near the end of cooking add gluten free potato starch, rice flour or other thickener (kuzu would be good though it’s a bit expensive, or arrowroot) just to give ia thicker consistency. Don’t skip the sauteeing spices part in any case, to bring out their flavors and to add a toasty quality.
Re: I don’t have any
I know this is late, but I am celiac, and I have indeed made a roux with rice flour. It works pretty much the same way.
Ok, I’ll try that. Thanks
Ok, I’ll try that. Thanks a lot!
Thanks!
I tried your recipe with the S & B base and I cannot believe how much difference adding extra onions, garlic, ginger and grated apple makes! I used to be lazy and just use carrots and potatoes with chicken, omitting even onions. I’m now obsessed with making the perfect curry, so thinking of making it with the garam marsala and curry powder rather than the base, and trying extra things like instant coffee powder. It was rather sweet just with your recipe, but I’m still keen to add a little sweet potato, and maybe even miso.
I might also vary it a little, make a vegetarian curry and stir in the meat before serving as I tend to use chicken. I use a pressure cooker so the vegetables are tender in next to no time. The slowest step is actually sauteeing the onions. Which cuts of beef and pork do you recommend? I haven’t had good results with blade steak, probably because the pressure cooker works too well. Skirt steak would probably be the same as chicken, requiring minimal cooking time. I haven’t tried pork at all so not sure which cuts to use.
Now, if only I can get tonkatsu right, then I can do kare katsu, my absolute favorite.
Post new comment