Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

fugu1.jpg

(Note: Your responses to the question posed below may be translated for a Japanese blog! Read on…)

Even though I’m Japanese, I do think that we eat an awful lot of food that could be considered to be odd. One of them is the infamous fugu, or puffer fish. Fugu’s main claim to fame, besides its extraordinary appearance (it puffs itself up to make itself look a lot bigger to predators), is that its skin and organs are highly poisonous. Nevertheless, it’s considered to be a great delicacy in Japan. It’s now fugu season in fact, so many people are tucking in to fugu sashi (fugu sashimi), fugu nabe (fugu hotpot), and so on.

In order to serve fugu, a chef has to go through a strict certification process. If an unskilled or careless person accidentally pierces the organs or otherwise contaminates the edible flesh of the fish, then the diner may find that meal to be his last. Despite all regulatory precautions, every year there are reports of people getting sick or even dying from fugu poisoning. Recently there was a case in Toyama prefecture, where nine people who partook of fugu at a sushi restaurant were taken ill; of the 2 people who lost consciousness, one is still in a coma. (Link to news story in Japanese - this hasn’t made the news in any English online media outlets as far as I can find out.)

Non-lethal fugu may be on its way to our tables, but fugu fans often cite the thrill of possible poisoning/death as part of the appeal of fugu. A few die-hards even like to put a tiny bit of the poison on their fugu, for that numbing/tingling sensation on the lips. I wonder if they liked to stick their tongues on batteries when they were kids. (This was in fact how a famous kabuki theater actor died of fugu poisoning, many years ago — he put a bit of the poisonous live on his fugu pieces.) In case you are wondering just how you die, it’s not a very nice way to go.

I’ve had fugu sashi, and while fresh fugu is indeed delicious, I am not sure if the risk of a very uncomfortable death, or an even more uncomfortable recovery time in the hospital, is worth it.

Fugu: Would you? Have you? What do you think of people who do?

So…what do you think about Japanese people (and others) who eat a highly poisonous food willingly? Does it say anything to you about Japanese culture or society?

Would you try fugu yourself? Have you tried it - and if so, what did you think? Was it worth it? (Note: Nippon Restaurant in New York was the first restaurant in the U.S. to serve fugu; there are a dozen or so other restaurants in the city that serve it now. I’m not sure about other cities though.)

Now as I said in the Note at top, your comments/answers to this question may be translated for the Japanese blog MHK - Maou Housou Kyoukai. This is a fun blog where various discussions around the interweb on all kinds of topics are translated into Japanese, for people who are curious about what ‘the world’ thinks, especially about Japan and Japanese people. The comments are quite interesting to say the least. This post was in fact inspired by a comment left there, and used with the owner Michiru-san’s blessing. So go ahead - now’s your chance to tell Japanese people what you really think!

Don't miss any more recipes and articles! Subscribe to Just Hungry via your newsreader or by email (more about subscriptions).
filed under

84 comments so far...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I'm looking at the puffer picture accompanying this post and want to poke it with a fork and eat it- the damn thing looks tasty. But would I indulge in Fugu? No thank you, there are plenty of other very tasty fish in the sea that don't risk a painful death. Better safe than sorry in my case.

Van | 30 November, 2009 - 23:09

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I probably would not. I can't say 100% that given the right time and place I never would, but it is not something I am seeking out.

I would be more likely to eat the non-poisonous variety mentioned in the article, for what it is worth.

As for people who do choose to eat it, well, that's their choice. There are many, many things that are more worth being upset over than other people eating a potentially dangerous fish. If that's what makes them happy, good for them.

I wonder how the numbers of people getting sick and/or dying from eating undercooked hamburgers compare to those eating fugu. I absolutely eat hamburgers rare, and you will not get me to stop, but it is not for the 'thrill'.

PlantingOaks | 30 November, 2009 - 23:39

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I had the pleasure of eating fugu five years ago at a 100+ year old, family-owned fugu restaurant in Tokyo (after a day of hiking on Fujisan, just to make it even more perfect). The meal included fugu soup, fugu face, fugu organs in a gelatin, the "chrysanthemum" presentation of fugu sashimi, and more. It all had a very delicate flavor, more delicate than hamachi or sake. There was no lip tingling that I could sense, and we all survived nicely. The multi-generational aspect of this restaurant was reassuring as I had heard that once your fugu fatally poisons a customer, you're no longer allowed to be in the fugu serving business. I'd eat it again, although it's so expensive, I think your money is better spent on Japan's many less notorious yet still "oishi" delicacies.

TomMorse | 1 December, 2009 - 00:38

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I am not sure. I wouldn't say definitely that I won't eat it, but it's not at the top of my list of things to try.
That said, if I knew that the chef was extremely skilled and experienced, I might try it.
I love all kinds of sashimi so it's possible. I think though, there are only two or maybe three places in the San Fransisco Bay Area that will serve it. And I think it's always special order ahead of time.
I think it's probably safer to eat than wild gathered mushrooms! Here each year there are at least one or two reports of whole families getting sick or dying form eating wild mushrooms.
Seems to usually be an immigrant family, so I'm guessing there is a mushroom here that looks just like an edible one back in their homeland. Except this one is poisonous!
Also, not a fun way to die!

So maybe I'll have Fugu for my 80th birthday party and if I live then I'll have a few more years left to try it again! ^^

BarbJ | 1 December, 2009 - 01:22

Fugu? I do! Don't you?

I am looking forward to trying fugu sashimi someday. Japan is pretty high on my list of travel destinations.

I think that it makes complete sense to eat something that you know how to cook properly. We all eat meat that we assume has been cleaned properly by a butcher. That same meat can be quite poisonous if the digestive tract is not removed properly.

I also think it is interesting that most Americans are afraid to eat something that is less likely to kill them than their drive home.

Stephano | 1 December, 2009 - 02:25

Re: Fugu? I do! Don't you?

Where does the "Americans" thing come from??? How random and needlessly critical. Also, there has been no majority of people, American or otherwise, saying they are "afraid"--just that it may not be a wise choice. Thanks for the random cheap shot though--you've just made yourself out to be no better than these "scared Americans" you mock.

anon. | 17 December, 2009 - 19:10

Re: Fugu? I do! Don't you?

Only one problem; I can treat you for food poisoning caused by the exposure to intestional byproduct contamination with a high rate of recovery and very few side effects, but fugu toxin poisoning almost always carries long term side effects and is almost impossible to treat completely. I can't see the appeal of the risk myself and, no, I won't be trying fugu in the forseeable future.

Bear | 16 January, 2010 - 08:20

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I ate fugu when I lived in Japan, and it was quite tasty. However, I didn't think it was a "to-die-for" level of deliciousness. I think it's worth trying once, so that you can impress your non-Japanese friends, but unless someone else is paying, I'm unlikely to eat fugu again.

Becky | 1 December, 2009 - 02:26

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I really like the fugu picture.
I have never tried fugu, and I don't know if I would. I'm not desperate to try it, but have never thought that I definitely wouldn't eat it, either.
My boyfriend just said from his napping-spot on the couch that he's had it, and that it was okay. He didn't think that it stood out as the most delicious fish he's had, and didn't feel his lips tingle or anything.
When reading a book called 'The Serpent and the Rainbow' (it was also a movie) years ago, I remember the author (Wade Davis) speculating that fugu poison may have been one element used in a poison that created real-life zombies in Haiti and the Caribbean.
Fugu is certainly an interesting food, at least for the mythological and cultural aspects! That said, I certainly hope that those recently poisoned by it get better...

meaghan | 1 December, 2009 - 02:45

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I've been in Japan for a while now but I've never had the chance of trying fugu. I would probably try it if someone else bought it for me but I wouldn't go out of my way to buy it myself. Even if I had the chance to try, I would probably just have a tiny bit, just to be able to say that I've tried fugu.

About other people, well it's their lives, so they can do whatever they want. Some people do bungee, other eat fugu. To each its own ;)

kanmuri | 1 December, 2009 - 03:00

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I at Fugu several times when I lived in rural Kyoto in 2003-2004. Delicious, light, and didn't seem at all dangerous. The only people we heard of dying at the time seemed to be unlicenced people who had tried to cook it themselves.

Katy | 1 December, 2009 - 03:04

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I would try fugu, not for any kind of thrill but out of sheer curiosity. I've gotten plenty of snide comments because I like eating raw fish (sushi) and here in Texas, they call that bait. If I'd listened to people trying to get me Not to eat it, I'd have been missing out. You're just as likely to get ill from the other kinds of sashimi and sushi the chef serves as you are from the fugu, in my opinion. Raw fish is, after all, raw. I don't know of any places that serve fugu in my part of Texas, but I haven't been looking either. I'm going to look now, though, just in case the opportunity presents itself for me to try it.

Bonnie Norman | 1 December, 2009 - 03:06

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

Thank you for reinforcing Texas stereotypes. While what you say may be true, there are NUMEROUS sushi and sushi-serving restaurants in Texas, and they are quite popular. I'm honestly not aware of anyone I know who would mock someone who enjoys sushi because most people I know--Texans--love it.

anon. | 17 December, 2009 - 19:14

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

Another Texan chiming in - I eat sushi happily, but get a lot of flack about it from about half of my friends. That's the thing about stereotypes and generalizations - they come from repeated actions and reactions from a definitive segment of the population, and I can attest that there are still many Texans out there who mock the eating of raw fish (though many of those will happily swallow bleeding steak).

As for fugu... I'm in the "no" category, not because it's dangerous - but because I keep puffers in my home aquarium and love them a little too much to eat one of their cousins.

Ali | 4 January, 2010 - 17:05

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

Maki, I hate all fish. I won't eat it. That being said, I went to a ryokan up in Nagano and most of the courses for dinner were fish. When fugu came along I figured "Why not?" It was deep fried, which is the most tolerable form of fish in my opinion and it was DELICIOUS. I loved it! I had heard that fugu gives a slight numbing sensation to the lips and mouth but I guess this had no poison. It tasted, well, like fried chicken. Not fishy at all. Light and juicy. Loved it!

Kristin | 1 December, 2009 - 03:31

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I would. But cautiously and at a reputable fugu place.

I read "The Serpent and the Rainbow", a book by an ethnobotonist searching for the ingredients to the Caribbean zombi powder. Two main ingredients were blowfish poison, to simulate death, and datura, to force mindlessness. He had a section about blowfish consumption, specifically fugu, and since then I have really wanted to try it. Not for the intent of reaching a near death state, but because of the risk/thrill of it.

Gexx | 1 December, 2009 - 03:46

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I have extremely bad luck so i know if i ever did try it something bad would happen. Im not ready to risk death for a good meal lol. Besides, the fish itself is too cute to eat. xD Id rather keep it as a pet haha.

Lufflee | 1 December, 2009 - 04:46

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

When I was in Japan as an exchange student ten years ago, my host father's birthday celebration include fugu sashimi, fugu hotpot and champagne. I found it rather decadent and knew it would be a great story to take back with me to the States. I would indulge again so long as I had no reason to suspect the preparing establishment. In terms of food-related deaths, I think you're almost more likely to choke to death on mochi. Perhaps not, but still, the risk of death from fugu is extremely low when compared to one's risk in general.

Kyshandra | 1 December, 2009 - 05:31

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I would probably not unless I went to Japan and to a reputable place. I love sashimi but am considering only eating sustainable fish. There are a couple of sushi restaurants in Seattle that offer this choice. :O)

Lori | 1 December, 2009 - 05:57

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

If I knew for absolute certain that it was a reliable chef who'd never had any incidents, I'd try it. But cooked, raw fish is something I simply cannot eat, I've tried and couldn't handle the texture. Still, I'm adventurous enough that I'd try it.

Aleria | 1 December, 2009 - 06:10

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

We had Fugu at Sushi Yasuda (in NYC) in May but it was the domestic type, bred poison-free. It was nice but not note-worthy. The Chef told me it tastes different in Japan so I'll likely try it when I'm in Japan one day, but I'll be doing a lot of research first.

Jessica Lee Binder | 1 December, 2009 - 06:15

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I had the chance to eat fugu several times during my time living in Japan. The first time was at a lovely restaurant in Osaka, and the other times were in Tokyo. I thoroughly enjoyed it every time. It's a mild, somewhat sweet fish, very nice as sashimi, and really good fried (but then, what isn't good fried?). I think that as long as the people who are preparing and serving it are licensed, then it's fine. If you look at the statistics of deaths from fugu, around 98% of the deaths from fugu were those where the fugu was prepared by people at home, uneducated in what they needed to know about preparing fugu. So while that does leave a small chance of going from poisoning at a restaurant, to me, it's not worse than the chances I take otherwise in life. I'm actually putting together a trip to take friends to a restaurant in NYC to partake of some fugu.

Shari | 1 December, 2009 - 06:30

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I had the chance to eat fugu several times during my time living in Japan. The first time was at a lovely restaurant in Osaka, and the other times were in Tokyo. I thoroughly enjoyed it every time. It's a mild, somewhat sweet fish, very nice as sashimi, and really good fried (but then, what isn't good fried?). I think that as long as the people who are preparing and serving it are licensed, then it's fine. If you look at the statistics of deaths from fugu, around 98% of the deaths from fugu were those where the fugu was prepared by people at home, uneducated in what they needed to know about preparing fugu. So while that does leave a small chance of going from poisoning at a restaurant, to me, it's not worse than the chances I take otherwise in life. I'm actually putting together a trip to take friends to a restaurant in NYC to partake of some fugu.

Shari | 1 December, 2009 - 06:30

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I have been to Japan on 2 separate occasions and was offered by my gracious Japanese friends a chance at eating Fugu, and I had refused both times. Fugu is so expensive, I certainly did not feel at all nice if we ate this dangerous dish and something happened- somehow the locals never felt it was dangerous, it probably was a Gaijin thingy.

I most certainly would not eat Fugu. There are so many fantastic food and simple delights at every corner in Japan that cost very little so why commit your life to something so expensive and possibly fatal.

Notwithstanding, being with the Japanese people and having studied your culture, I think everything Japanese is set in rigid rules and regulations. There is also so much protocol to follow for everything one undertakes- from traveling (Japanese guidebooks tell you specifically what to do, what to eat etc) to the trivial (there is a shocking number of guidelines available).

I think the act of eating Fugu equalizes everyone. While there is ranking outside but at the table, everyone is an equal, partaking an equal amount of risks and of their own choice.

Also, since everything has a rigid sort of outcome, the risks of eating Fugu provides a romantic notion of something different. While the outcome could be quite disastrous but I think from reading enough Japanese literature, that death is a romantic ideal too.

Low KL | 1 December, 2009 - 08:29

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

Fugu. Yes I have tried it but wouldn't go out of my way to have it again. My father occasionally prepares it and feeds it to the family. He eats it first before he served it up to the rest of the family. But he's catches the blowfish himself and has been fishing and preparing fish since he was able to walk. Taste fairly light and pleasant but there are tastier things in the world that don't have the chance to kill me instantly.

salee | 1 December, 2009 - 08:46

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

I don't think I would try this, I think it's too risky and I'm not really attracted to danger in general.

emeline | 1 December, 2009 - 11:00

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

In my pre-Vegan days I have eaten fugu in Dotonbori, Osaka. Totally underwhelming. I had sashimi and tempura. Really not a big deal, I have eaten weirder stuff than fugu.

Megami | 1 December, 2009 - 11:58

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

While I would be curious to taste fugu and have trust in the chefs to prepare it in a non-poisonous way, I recently saw a documentary about fugu on tv, that shocked me. Apparently they cut up the fish while it is still alive to have it served as fresh as possible! The fish is fileted in full consciousness, with the chefs taking care not to pierce any of the inner organs so it will stay alive as along as possible! I find that so incredible, nightmarishly cruel, I would never eat this fish at a restaurant, where this way of preparing fugu is practiced. (This reminded me of a 'recipe' from the middle ages I once read, that had instructions for roasting a duck in a way that it would be still alive while being eaten. Horrible and unnecessary!)
The fish would not be any less fresh if it had been killed right before cutting it up and serving, so I don't understand why it is done that way?

But I would certainly try fugu if I knew they had killed it BEFORE cutting it up.

Stefanie | 1 December, 2009 - 12:59

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

first i was going to say no , but on second thoughts i probably would , it's the same thing with wild mushrooms which are one of my favorites

anon. | 1 December, 2009 - 13:42

Re: Fugu (puffer fish): Would you or wouldn't you?

Considering that I currently find myself living in Shimonoseki which is the fugu-capital of Japan (everything from the busses to the sewer lids are branded with cartoon fugu) I have had the chance to try it. It is indeed delicious, though no tingling lips or sensation of any sort. I've so far only been able to try fugu sushi but I look forward to trying fugu nabe sometime soon... there was a big festival about a week ago to celebrate the launch of fugu season!

tantousha | 1 December, 2009 - 15:30

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br>
  • Each email address will be obfuscated in a human readble fashion or (if JavaScript is enabled) replaced with a spamproof clickable link.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

You can change the default for this field in "Comment follow-up notification settings" on your account edit page.

Related sites

wfp banner img
freerice234_60_Banner2.jpg

Hello!

Just Hungry is a site about Japanese food and home cooking, healthy eating, the expat food life, and more. [log in] or [register]

About this site

maki Just Hungry is a site about food. There are lots of recipes and much more. You may want to take the grand tour, read about Just Hungry, or contact the site owner, Makiko Itoh. To dive in real deep, try the site map.

Sharing!

  • tech-fav-1.gif
This article is from justhungry.com.