It's The Season For Shepherd's Pie


Having spent some of my growing-up years in England, I have a special place in my heart for shepherd's pie, otherwise known as cottage pie. It's definitely winter food though, because nothing is as warming as piping hot shepherd's pie straight out of the oven.

It combines two of my favorite ingredients, well-seasoned ground beef and mashed potatoes. Actually I believe that originally the ground meat was lamb, but in our house lamb was a no-no since my father had a morbid dislike of it. (One famous family story is when he was invited to dinner when we were living in England. He took a mouthful of the roast he was served, and asked his hostess what it was. She said it was lamb, and he promptly and spectacularly threw up.) I don't mind lamb myself but some family traditions are sacred: beef it is for shepherd's pie.

I've made the ground beef part with a lot of variations over the years, but I've settled on this formula as being the most tasty. The key to its tastiness is the slowly sautéed mushroom mixture, which is (when made with butter rather than oil, though it's good even if you use healthier olive oil) a standard in classical French cooking called duxelles. Classic duxelles does not use celery but I like to add a small piece of celery nevertheless.

You can make the beef part in advance, and even freeze it, which makes it a nice easy-assembly dinner; but whatever you do please use freshly made mashed potatoes. Below I reveal how I make my mash.

Shepherd's Pie

  • 500g, or about 1 lb, not-too-lean ground beef
  • 250g, or about 1/2 pound or 1 packet, mushrooms
  • 1 medium onion
  • 1 piece celery stalk
  • 1-2 garlic cloves
  • 4-6 (depending on size) creamy potatoes. Here I prefer Bintje potatoes, in the U.S. I would use Yukon Gold
  • Whole Milk
  • Worcestershire Sauce
  • About 1 cup vegetable or beef stock (water + stock cube is fine)
  • Salt, pepper and dried thyme

Preheat the oven to about 200°C / 400°F.

Chop the onion, celery, garlic and mushrooms finely. Saute the onion, celery and garlic until tender. Add the mushrooms and saute until the water that comes out of the mushrooms has more or less evaporated. Add about 1/2 tsp. of dried thyme. Add the ground beef and cook through. Add a few dashes of Worcestershire sauce. Season a bit on the strong side with salt and pepper. Finally, add about 1 cup of water or stock to make it a bit sauce-like; cook down a bit to concentrate the flavors.

In the meantime, boil the potatoes in salted water in their skins, until tender and you can stick a skewer through one easily. If you have a potato ricer you can rice the potatoes with their skins on; otherwise, peel them (holding them with a kitchen towel) then mash with a potato masher. Stir the mashed potatoes around in a dry pan over fairly low heat until it's dried out. Turn up the heat to about medium, and make a well in the middle of the potato mash. Pour in some milk (about 3/4 - 1 cup or so for this amount) into the well, and drop as big a piece of butter as you dare into it. Now, leave it be (don't stir) until the milk is bubbling and the butter has almost completely melted. Then, whip the potatoes vigorously with a wooden spoon. Season with salt and pepper to taste - keep it on the slightly bland side.

Spread the beef mixture on the bottom of oven dishes that are attractive enough to take straight to the table. (I use round enameled cast-iron ones.) Spread the mashed potatoes on top of this - the potato should completely cover the beef, to a depth of at least 1.5cm / 1/2 inch or so. Score the top of the potato with a fork, and then sprinkle a bit of Worcestershire sauce on top. Dot with as many bits of butter as you dare.

Bake in the oven for about 25-30 minutes until the top is browned. Eat straight out of the oven (have a glass of cold water handy for when a very hot piece burns a bit too much).

Serves 4 normal people or 2 very hungry people.

Filed under:  dinner potatoes winter pie favorites beef ground meat

If you enjoyed this article, please consider becoming my patron via Patreon. ^_^

Become a Patron!


Yummy! missed shepherd's pie. i like mine with some kidney in it.

Ah, I can relate to your dad. As for me, the food that my body somehow resists happens to be mushrooms. If I even get a taste of it my mind start to nauseate. I'd love to try out this recipe but I was wondering perhaps if there were some other suitable substitute to all the mushroom related ingredients? I'd greatly appreciate it.

Daniel, try the Louisiana Creole/Cajun 'holy trinity' of finely chopped onion, celery, and bell peppers - this also tastes great. Or you can also try the French mirepoix mix which is shallots (you can use onion and garlic instead), carrots, and celery - again, chopped fine and sauteed in oil or butter until limp before you add the ground meat.

There are two different dishes, based on which meat you use.

Made with minced lamb, it's Shepard's Pie; with minced beef, it's Cottage Pie.

So you are making it correctly :)

I recommend adding a bit of soured cream and grated cheddar cheese to the potato mash, it's loverly.

*sigh* I wish I could spell. :P

Thanks alot Maki, this recipe worked charms!

That's what we call "Hâchis Parmentier" in France. I love it, but the meat has to be very finely ground (I'm a little bit... maniacal with that).

Thanks for your tip about frozing it ;)

shouldn't it be 200C / 400F?

i was looking for a shepherd's pie recipe because, you're right, it's the season for it. XD

You are right of course. Corrected! (darn typos :))

I learned to make this with just canned vegies (whatever is on hand) and layer browned ground meat, drained canned veggies (I have been known to throw in some fresh veggies to clean out the fridge) then 2-3 cans of cream of mushroom soup, top with mashed potatoes and bake.

yummy looking! In England shepherds pie is lamb with mix vegetables like carrots, peas and sweetcorn. Cottage pie has mince beef but no vegetables, i guess this is like a combo of them both!

At my house, we throw in as many veggies as possible with the meat. The usuals are peas, carrots, celery, and onions, but we've been known to use eggplant, green beans, tomatoes, and corn too. Pretty much anything we have on hand can go in. ;)

My mom also makes a mean Mexican version with a chipotle seasoned beef and black beans mixture topped with sweet potatoes and cheese. It's the best thing ever on a cold day!