A belated review of Ratatouille

ratatouille-movie.jpgYesterday, we finally got to see Ratatouille (the movie that is, not the dish), when it opened in western or French-speaking Switzerland. The movie theater in Lausanne was only sparsely filled, though since the weather was so glorious, and it was Swiss National Day (sort of like Independence Day in the U.S. in terms of the way in which people celebrate it, with barbeques and fireworks) I guess that was sort of understandable. Anyway, my review, with many spoilers, follows after the jump.

I’ve been a big Pixar fan ever since I saw the Luxor Jr. short many years ago. I have all of their movies on DVD. Despite the fact that Ratatouille combines three of my favorite things - Pixar, France, and the love of food - I don’t think it’s a perfect movie by any means - and, dare I say, not quite Pixar’s best either. (I happen to think that Toy Story 2 is their best.) That’s not to say I didn’t love it - I did, absolutely.

Like most other food lovers who’ve reviewed this movie, I adored the details - the burn marks on the chef’s arms, the logical and realistic layout of the kitchen at Gusteau’s, the explanation of mis en place by Colette. I loved the passion of Remy, who is, despite his ratness, a true artist. The animation and the artistry is, as with all Pixar movies, unsurpassed - it could be their best in that respect ever. (Whenever there was a scene with a swarm of rats, I couldn’t help cringing.)

I think what keeps the movie from being a real masterpiece is the weakness of some of the characters, especially Linguini. He rather reminds me of a typical Disney prince, in that he’s a non-character. Sure, he can’t cook, but it’s not really explained to my satisfaction anyway why he would endure having a rat pulling on his hair for so long - sure he wants to keep the job, but… I just found him to be quite unsatisfactory somehow.

I also wanted just a bit more about Skinner. What made him such a bitter, mean and small (not just in stature, but in thought and deed) man. Did being a sous chef to a chef with so many accolates ruin him? Was he destined never to be great himself, which is why he’s so bitter and out to destroy his former boss’s reputation? Is he Salieri to Gusteau’s Mozart? I know there’s a length limit to any movie, but I just wanted a little bit more there.

Speaking of sous-chefs…I thought that Colette, who by the end of the movie is effectively Remy’s sous chef in their new restaurants, was somewhat underwritten too. It did seem that she was destined to be a sous chef rather than the chief, the artist - she can recreate recipes flawlessly, but she can’t seem to create her own. This is rather interesting in light of what happened to Skinner. I suppose this was done to enhance the stature of Remy as the one, great artist in the piece.

Another bit of nitpicking I have, which I know is really esoteric, is the way in which the actual cooking/creative process of Remy is demonstrated, especially with the infamous soup. It plays up the cliché image of French cooking: add this, that and the other ingredient, more and more of them, until you end up with something delicious. I rather think that this just goes against all that is modern about cooking, and is certainly not the way the best chefs in French cook now. But I know, we are talking about an animated movie here…

There is one moment that really does raise Ratatouille to great heights: when Ego tastes Remy’s ratatouille, and is instantly transported back to a happy moment in his childhood. That moment of pure joy, of transcendence, is what great food can bring - and those few seconds captured that rapturous feeling so perfectly.

(A note for anyone in Switzerland: I’d thought that Ratatouille opening was delayed in the German speaking part until October because of subtitling problems. Well that doesn’t seem to be the case since the movie did have German and French subs! I’ll never understand the distribution system of movies in Switzerland where a part of the country gets a movie months before another…it’s so illogical. More thoughts about this on my personal blog.

We also thought about going to see it in France because we thought it would be fun to see it with a French audience, but we couldn’t find any theater within reasonable daytripping distance showing it in non-dubbed form. Boo to dubbed movies. At least here in Switzerland there are many theaters showing movies in the original language, as opposed to Germany and France where they tend to dub everything.)

Don't miss any more recipes and articles! Subscribe to Just Hungry via your newsreader or by email (more about subscriptions).
filed under

3 comments so far...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Great review!

While I’ve read many a review on Ratatouille, I appreciate this review. I do agree that some of the characters you specified were underwritten, but certainly not all. I thought Linguine’s character was quite well done, as they exploited his awkwardness and desperation to succeed, meaning he’ll do anything, even have a rat pull on his hair if it works. But, I had a problem with that actual “solution.” Not that all movies are expected to be realistic, it was quite unrealistic in a situation where you needed something more functional for you to really want Remy (a rat for goodness sake) to be in the kitchen. No one’s body/limbs are controlled by the hairs in their head. In terms of Collette, I could definitely have used more insight into her character, she seemed to have many different sides to her but we never saw any transition between them (When/how did she fall for Linguine?) In terms of Skinner, I thought he was developed fine enough for the function he played in the movie: the bully, the enemy and the obstacle. That’s all that was necessary for him; if too many people are personified, we won’t know who to feel for.

Thanks for this!

Hillary | 3 August, 2007 - 20:26

Thought it was a great film...

Ohh…nice review.
I thought the movie was pretty good. It could have used a bit more character development like you mentioned, but that could have extended the movie more than it needed to be.
The storyline, overall, I thought was just great, and the animation was amazing. I usually don’t go for animated films in the theaters (I feel like I’m paying to watch a cartoon hahah), but actually, in this case I’m really glad that I went for it. And now, I’ve got to find out some more about the other movies you jotted down in your top 10 list…

inersion | 6 August, 2007 - 02:26

Ooooooh Tampopo!

Haven’t seen the movie. Probably I’ll wait until it comes on TV as animation is not really my thing, unless it’s quirky and weird enough (think “The Cat Came Back” and “Spinnolio”) but I have to agree with you about “Tampopo”. It was my first Japanese movie and it cast such a spell that I think it may be one of the reasons I came to Japan. Guess which food I was desperate to eat first, and I ate it every week the first year I was here, in a little neighborhood ramen shop with a daily special that included gyoza, pickles and rice. Probably a whole day’s calories in that one meal, but glorious. White miso vegetable ramen, mmmmmm.

I haven’t seen all the movies on your list but I agree with the ones I have and I’ll keep an eye out for the others. Thanks! :)

vegetablej | 7 August, 2007 - 02:32

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br>
  • Each email address will be obfuscated in a human readble fashion or (if JavaScript is enabled) replaced with a spamproof clickable link.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Related sites

Share food, change lives
Play Freerice and feed the hungry

Hello!

Just Hungry is a site about Japanese food and home cooking, healthy eating, the expat food life, and more. [log in] or [register]

About this site

maki Just Hungry is a site about food. There are lots of recipes and much more. You may want to read about Just Hungry, or contact the site owner, Makiko Itoh. To dive in real deep, try the site map.

This article is from justhungry.com.