Top Chef Season 2 Episode 12 (Finale part 1)

I am mildly surprised that Marcel and Ilan won this round, to go through to the final head to head. Though I must admit that at this point I don't really care much about the outcome since I don't care much about any of the four semi-finalists. The whole Elia accusing Marcel of 'cheating' sequence (with zero shown support from Ilan or Sam) was so awkward I'd rather forget it.

The food was quite interesting, but I've never been to Hawaii. It's definitely on my list of must-go-to-someday places, especially since there are strong ties to Japanese culture there. (Besides, I often get mistaken for being from Hawaii...not sure why!) But I've never really had Hawaiian food, so I don't know what poi or any of the other foods that the contestants were supposed to emulate, or evoke, in their dishes are like. So I felt like a blind person trying to appreciate colors when looking at the dishes for the challenge. Once again, this points out the disadvantages of a food or cooking show contest. We can only trust what the judges say about what they are eating.

Cooking = applying heat?

One thing I really objected to was the comment/view expressed, especially by Tom Colicchio, that Sam didn't do much because he didn't 'cook' anything. Does cooking mean you have to heat food in some way? That's ridiculous. "Cooking" with acid is a valid process. Putting ingredients together is a valid process. It shows a bias against cuisines that do not heat all of their food. It may have been a nitpicking detail they used as an excuse to differentiate the contestants, but it was frankly silly. Is foaming up xanthum gum and pineapple juice 'cooking'? I guess the judges thought so, since Marcel passed.

A chemical un-romance

The number people that actually care about what is going on in the higher echelons of haute cuisine are probably just a tiny fraction of the population. And the number of those who have actually gone to a 'molecular gastronomy' restaurant are a small fraction of that (mainly because they are mostly located in a few cities, and they are all prohibitively expensive). It's safe to assume that way, way more people watch the Top Chef show from the comfort of their sofas.

So it's likely that Marcel has, for better or worse, introduced this 'molecular gastronomy' (which I put in quotes since the practitioners of this say we aren't to call it that anymore) stuff to more Americans than all the 'real' chefs who are proponents of this kind of cooking combined. Because his interpersonal skills (at least in front of a camera) and presentational skills (ditto) are so horrible, this is probably a bad thing for the movement. He's not a master of the methods, his judgement is not always right, and the foam has become a running joke. The methodology of 'molecular gastronomy' seems weird, sci-fi-ish and eccentric in any case to the casual viewer. It would have done the movement a ton of good if well-liked Sam for instance had been the resident MGist of the season. I'm not a wholehearted fan of the movement myself (I've noted before the similarities with the methods used and the industrial food manufacturing methods employed by big corporations, and wondered what the big deal really is) but it's a shame if one rather immature young man can do this. (In contrast, the recent BBC series starring Heston Blumenthal was a much better intro to the movement, from an acknowledged master. I hope it makes it over to BBC America someday so people in the U.S. can compare.) Not that the producers of Top Chef care anything about educating the public, I'm sure.

So...who's going to win? The logical choice might be Ilan, who despite some weak moments has mostly survived unscathed by too much controversy. But then, not-liked Jeffrey did win the last season of Project Runway...

Filed under:  top chef tv

If you enjoyed this article, please consider becoming my patron via Patreon. ^_^

Become a Patron!


I think it's interesting because unlike other reality shows like American Idol, where personality and looks DO matter, and it's not just about the raw talent, Top Chef, or the judges at least, keeps reminding us that it's "about the food." Perhaps it should be, but where does that leave the viewer, who can't taste the food? The product, unlike with American Idol, is largely inaccessible to us.

Another great TC commentary Maki...

Frankly, I'm hoping this entire, sad season of TC ends by Marcel kicking Ilan's a**... Why? It's certainly not because Marcel's immature and slightly bizarre, and certainly not due to any love of MGonmy. Simply because,save for Mikey, Marcel is the only non-mean spirited contestant during this entire season. He's also played it like a contest, not a soap opera, and that's why he's here, foams and all.

I really respect people who have a sincere passion and enthusiasm for what they do and Marcel, for all of his many faults and quirks, is one of the few contestants to have displayed just that.

As one of his coworkers said at the beginning of the episode, something like, "I've never seen anyone so eager to learn more about food and how it works than Marcel," I can believe it and I wish him luck...

After he wins, I then wish the entire TC staff luck in tuning up the show after this sad, bitter season into something less disspiriting and, dare I wish it, fractionally educational.

BTW: If you folks haven't heard them, the podcast interviews of the contestants voted off each week are on, and are great, and really flesh these people out (and show how the show is really conducted by the producers).

Mike's podcast with stories of his tooth extraction were particularly hilarious!

great comments Garris! I agree with everything you said.

It was sad to see people whom I respected previously (Elia, Ilan, etc.) become so bitter, childlike, and and whiny towards the end. Marcel is a little what? Is Anthony Bourdain any less self-promoting? Think Mario Batali would have hugged and kissed Betty in the midst of her kitchen foul-ups? I think not.
I think there was an inventiveness and creativity that Marcel demonstrated that the others did not. Ilan's endless, been there, done that recreations of Spanish dishes did not inspire me at all.
Sad how this season lost sight of food.

hello maki! forgive the indulgence, but i am sitting in the honolulu airport with a 3 hour layover, and a "top chef" marathon in front of me....i only watched the premiere episode of this season previously, and now am watching the hawaii episode (ironic); i don't know anything about the personalities of everyone but really, ilan's and marcel's dishes were very much in the spirit of hawaiian cuisine. tom mentioned in the previous comment that ilan recreates spanish dishes--his morcilla and squid dish is redolent of the portuguese and okinawan influences in hawaiian cooking, and marcel's hamachi poke with pineapple poi is eerily similar to a poke dish that i've had at judge alan wong's restaurant.

i don't know how the other episodes went, but i really think that the food these two presented in this challenge rightfully earned them spots in the final.